Menu
aPPETIZERS
Thinly sliced Eggplant, Breaded, Fried & Baked, Topped with Red Sauce & Cheese
* Only available at Siesta Key location.
Homemade Olive Oil Crostinis, Topped with Diced Fresh Tomatoes Red Onion & Basil, Drizzled with Balsamic Glaze & Goat Cheese
Served with a side of Red Sauce
Two House Made Meatballs, topped with Red Sauce and Parmesan Cheese
* Only available at Siesta Key location.
* Only available at Siesta Key location.
SALADS
Roasted Red Pepper and Goat Cheese
Tomatoes & Fresh Mozzarella Over lettuce, Fresh Basil, with Olive Oil & Balsamic Vinegar
Kalamata Olives, Red Onion, Tomato, Artichokes, Roasted Red Peppers, Pepperoncini, Feta Cheese, with Olive Oil & Balsamic Vinegar
Diced Italian Meats, Provolone, Tomato, Red Onion, Green Pepper, Artichoke, Giardiniera with Olive Oil & Balsamic Vinegar
Romaine Lettuce, Caesar Dressing, Parmesan Cheese & Homemade Croutons
Tomato, Red Onion, Fresh Green Peppers, Black Olives, Cheese with Olive Oil & Balsamic Vinegar
Tomato, Red Onion, Dried Cranberries, Goat Cheese & Raspberry Vinaigrette
Toppings
Banana Peppers, Bell Peppers, Black Olives, Capers, Cherry Peppers, Extra Sauce, Fresh Garlic, Fresh Tomatoes, Mushrooms, Pineapple, Red Onions
Artichoke, Bacon & Sausage, Basil, Kalamata Olives, Extra Cheese, Green Olives, Ham, Jalapenos, Meat Balls, Pepperoni, Pepperocini, Red Peppers, Ricotta Cheese, Spinach
Feta Cheese
Anchovies, Arugula, Crispy Eggplant, Fresh Mozzarella, Goat Cheese, Prosciutto
Grilled Chicken
Breakfast Pizza
Desserts
Large $4.00
Small $2.50
Sandwiches (Hot or Cold)
Peppered ham, capicola, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomato,
onion, olive oil, balsamic vinegar
Prosciutto, provolone, lettuce, tomato, olive oil, Balsamic Vinegar
Turkey, swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion
Roasted Red Peppers, Olives, Tomatoes, Artichokes,
Red Onion, choice of Cheese
Hot Sandwiches
With or Without Sauce & Cheese
Foccacia Sandwich
add fries to any sandwich for $3 or chips for $1.50
By The Slice
Drinks
- Coke Products
- Red Bull
- Soft Drinks
- Coffee & Tea
- Packaged Goods
- Beer & Wine
hAND tOSSED pIZZAS
Ricotta, Mozzarella, Parmesan & Red Sauce
Chicken, Onions, Mushrooms & BBQ Sauce
Mozzarella, Chicken & Ranch
Mozzarella & Red Sauce
Chicken, Onions, Tomatos, Arugula & Balsamic Glaze
Fresh Basil, Butter Clams, Red Sauce & Mozzarella
Hand-Breaded Crispy Eggplant, Mozzarella & Red Sauce
Pepperoni, Sausage, Green Peppers, Onions, Mushroom & Black Olive
Chicken, Green Peppers, Onions, & White Sauce
Plain Cheese
Goat Cheese, Mozzarella & Olive Oil (white or red)
Arugula, Goat Cheese, Mozzarella, Roasted Red Peppers & Olive Oil, (white or red)
Romaine Lettuce, Black Olives, Artichokes & Feta Cheese
Ricotta, Mozzarella, Garlic, Olive Oil & Grilled Chicken
Italian Ham, Pineapple, Mozzarella & Red Sauce
Chicken, Bacon, Pineapple & Hawaiian BBQ Sauce
Italian Ham, Shaved Red Onions, Mozzarella & Red Sauce
Italian Sausage, Mozzarella & Red Sauce
White or Red, Olive Oil, Roasted Red Peppers, Onions, Sausage, Ricotta & Jalapenos
Mozzarella, Red Sauce Fresh Tomatoes & Basil
Pepperoni, Sausage, Ham, Bacon & Meatballs
Homemade Meatballs, Mozzarella & Red Sauce
Black Olives, Artichokes, Mozzarella & Red Sauce
Pepperoni, Mozzarella & Red Sauce
Pepperoni, Bacon, Mozzarella & Red Sauce
Mozzarella, Provolone, Oil & Vinegar, Oil & Vinegar, Capicola, Salami & Peppered Ham
Our homemade thick crust baked with Olive Oil
Chopped Spinach, Mozzarella, Ricotta & Red Sauce
Olive Oil, Garlic, Mozzarella, Fresh Tomato, Basil & Prosciutto
Spinach, Mushrooms, Onions, Olives, Green Peppers, Tomatoe & Garlic
Spinach, Onion, Mushroom, Ricotta & Olive Oil
Tomato, Ricotta & Olive Oil
cREATE yOUR oWN
Additional toppings from $1.00 - $5.00 each
Includes Mozzarella
Includes Mozzarella & Ricotta Cheese
Entrees
* Only available at Siesta Key location.
House Made Meatballs served with Spaghetti and Red Sauce
Free Range Organic Boneless Chicken Breast & Fried Then Baked in Red Sauce and Topped with Fresh Cheese, served with your choice of Fresh Farm Vegetables or Spaghetti.
Eggplant, Breaded & Fried then Baked in Red Sauce and topped with fresh Cheese, served with your choice of Farm Fresh Vegetables or Spaghetti
Mild Italian Sausage, Roasted Red Peppers, Onion, Garlic, Fresh Basil, and Olive Oil, served over Pasta. Choice of: Olive & Garlic or House Red Sauce
Penne Pasta Baked in House Red Sauce with Mozzarella Cheese
Slide title
Always good pizza, always good service.
- Sarah K.
-
Great Pizza! Authentic New York Style Pizza in Sarasota! Love the thin crust! Highly Recommend!
- Dave B.
-
The best pizza in town bar none
- Walt L.
Button -
My friend and I were craving New York pizza, so we went to the downtown location for lunch. Pizza was delicious and flavorful, loved the interior decor. The employees were very friendly too.
While we were there, a homeless woman came in and looked in the trash can for leftover pizza. The restaurant (understandably) told her she had to leave, and one of the guys making the pizza, who was on break, went and gave her the rest of his lunch. She started crying she was so happy. The manager told me that they regularly give food to the homeless that come in. I know the complications that must arise from giving away free food to the homeless, so I appreciate even more how much the restaurant keeps their hearts open to the needy. Three thumbs up Il Panicicio. We will be back, and will bring our friends. ❤
Stylish interior · Large portions · Great food
- Cryistal S.
-
Slide title
Best Authentic Italian Food
- Raymond R.
-
Calzones to die for!
Ricotta cheese is the secret ingredient. OK, maybe it's not a secret, since it lists it on their menu, but it is what makes the Calzones taste amazing.
If I lived near here I would weigh 300 pounds (or more).
- S9528UUryanc
Button -
Slide title
Their sauce rocked my world!
Had an absolutely fabulous lunch at Il Panificio. Started by sharing a slice of their Sicilian Pizza with my wife. Crunchy, delicious crust; fresh, plentiful cheese; and incredible sauce. Then had a Chicken Parm sub. Oh my! The roll was perfect with just the right crust, chicken was delicious, fresh parm, and again... oh that sauce! Prices were reasonable. We'll try all their locations.
Button -
Slide title
Large pie reasonably priced. We had the cheese pizza and it was good. Thin crust with cornmeal on the bottom. Not a lot of sauce or cheese, but kinda like the pizza we got in Italy. I would go back.
- newyorker1953
-
Slide title
Finally good pizza in South Sarasota!
We have always been a fan of Panificios thin crust pizza and were disappointed when they closed the Gateway Ave. location. We recently ordered carry out at the new Reynolds Rd, location, around the corner from Mello Mushroom. When we arrived the pizza was just coming out of the oven piping hot. We ordered 3 large pizzas and they were prepared exactly as we ordered and as crispy and tasty as we remembered!
- danield278
Button -
Great pizza with no garlic!
Unfortunately I can no longer tolerate onions and garlic in my old age. This place makes great pizzas with no garlic, but they’d be great pizzas by any measure. The branch near Siesta Key seems to be having a problem with their relocation, but check the downtown location if they don’t figure this out soon. Delicious!
- Gene K
-
Great Authentic Italian Pizza! Also has sandwiches, sodas, juices, desserts, etc. - GREAT staff that work there, always friendly, always helpful, all positives other than the price is VERY reasonable... So it's "positive" but, better said is that the pricing is VERY reasonable. I had lunch twice the past week there- Pizza + 2 Candy bars + Soda = UNDER $10! (Im 6' 4" - 205lbs; so I eat a good amount) - so me going out to eat anywhere for a full meal is usually will over $10... NIGHT CREW: Special thx to the night crew, they are always kind and helpful and hard-working! My office is down street, so I'm there often. OUTSIDE SEATING: There is outside available as well as inside. It's beautiful outside this time of year. I attached a picture to this review of my view as I eat outside and worked on my iPad.
- Chris S.
Button -
Slide title
Slices! Whole pie. Thin and thick. They have beer and wine, too.
- Tim R.
Button -
I'm Italian. Sicilian actually. This is my go-to pizza place for the past 25 years. Always. Only. It's the best pizza in town. A little pricey. A large is going to run you 24 bucks. worth it. Serves beer and wine.
- Anthony M.
-
Slide title
Always good pizza, always good service.
- Sarah K.
-
Great Pizza! Authentic New York Style Pizza in Sarasota! Love the thin crust! Highly Recommend!
- Dave B.
-
The best pizza in town bar none
- Walt L.
Button -
My friend and I were craving New York pizza, so we went to the downtown location for lunch. Pizza was delicious and flavorful, loved the interior decor. The employees were very friendly too.
While we were there, a homeless woman came in and looked in the trash can for leftover pizza. The restaurant (understandably) told her she had to leave, and one of the guys making the pizza, who was on break, went and gave her the rest of his lunch. She started crying she was so happy. The manager told me that they regularly give food to the homeless that come in. I know the complications that must arise from giving away free food to the homeless, so I appreciate even more how much the restaurant keeps their hearts open to the needy. Three thumbs up Il Panicicio. We will be back, and will bring our friends. ❤
Stylish interior · Large portions · Great food
- Cryistal S.
-
Slide title
Best Authentic Italian Food
- Raymond R.
-
Calzones to die for!
Ricotta cheese is the secret ingredient. OK, maybe it's not a secret, since it lists it on their menu, but it is what makes the Calzones taste amazing.
If I lived near here I would weigh 300 pounds (or more).
- S9528UUryanc
Button -
Slide title
Their sauce rocked my world!
Had an absolutely fabulous lunch at Il Panificio. Started by sharing a slice of their Sicilian Pizza with my wife. Crunchy, delicious crust; fresh, plentiful cheese; and incredible sauce. Then had a Chicken Parm sub. Oh my! The roll was perfect with just the right crust, chicken was delicious, fresh parm, and again... oh that sauce! Prices were reasonable. We'll try all their locations.
Button -
Slide title
Large pie reasonably priced. We had the cheese pizza and it was good. Thin crust with cornmeal on the bottom. Not a lot of sauce or cheese, but kinda like the pizza we got in Italy. I would go back.
- newyorker1953
-
Slide title
Finally good pizza in South Sarasota!
We have always been a fan of Panificios thin crust pizza and were disappointed when they closed the Gateway Ave. location. We recently ordered carry out at the new Reynolds Rd, location, around the corner from Mello Mushroom. When we arrived the pizza was just coming out of the oven piping hot. We ordered 3 large pizzas and they were prepared exactly as we ordered and as crispy and tasty as we remembered!
- danield278
Button -
Great pizza with no garlic!
Unfortunately I can no longer tolerate onions and garlic in my old age. This place makes great pizzas with no garlic, but they’d be great pizzas by any measure. The branch near Siesta Key seems to be having a problem with their relocation, but check the downtown location if they don’t figure this out soon. Delicious!
- Gene K
-
Great Authentic Italian Pizza! Also has sandwiches, sodas, juices, desserts, etc. - GREAT staff that work there, always friendly, always helpful, all positives other than the price is VERY reasonable... So it's "positive" but, better said is that the pricing is VERY reasonable. I had lunch twice the past week there- Pizza + 2 Candy bars + Soda = UNDER $10! (Im 6' 4" - 205lbs; so I eat a good amount) - so me going out to eat anywhere for a full meal is usually will over $10... NIGHT CREW: Special thx to the night crew, they are always kind and helpful and hard-working! My office is down street, so I'm there often. OUTSIDE SEATING: There is outside available as well as inside. It's beautiful outside this time of year. I attached a picture to this review of my view as I eat outside and worked on my iPad.
- Chris S.
Button -
Slide title
Slices! Whole pie. Thin and thick. They have beer and wine, too.
- Tim R.
Button -
I'm Italian. Sicilian actually. This is my go-to pizza place for the past 25 years. Always. Only. It's the best pizza in town. A little pricey. A large is going to run you 24 bucks. worth it. Serves beer and wine.
- Anthony M.
