Skip to main content

Best Pizza in Siesta Key

Authentic Jersey style pizza, made in Sarasota since 1991.

IL Panificio Siesta

215 Avenida Madera, Siesta Key, FL 34242 +1 941-800-5570 Sunday – Thursday: 9:00 AM – 9:00 PM Friday – Saturday: 9:00 AM – 10:00 PM

Siesta Key

Steps from the world's best beach. Grab a slice, crack a beer, and settle in — you're on island time now.
Right in the Village

Right in the Village

We're on Avenida Madera in the heart of Siesta Key village — a short walk from the beach, the farmers market, and the Sunset Pier. Flip-flops welcome.
The Real Deal on the Island

The Real Deal on the Island

Crispy thin crust, house-made sauce, and fresh toppings — the same recipes we've been making since 1991. Grab a whole pie or a single slice to go.
Find Us

Find Us

215 Avenida Madera, Siesta Key, FL 34242. Call us at (941) 800-5570. Parking in the village fills fast in season — the beach access points are an easy walk.
Our Three Locations

Our Three Locations

Visit any of our three locations and enjoy the same authentic Italian recipes, fresh ingredients, and warm family hospitality. Whether you're visiting our original Downtown Sarasota location, our Siesta Key restaurant, or our Sarasota location at 1995 Main St, you'll experience the same family recipes and welcoming atmosphere.